Which is better: Orbital Sander or Random Orbital Sander?

Which is better, orbital or eccentric sander? A guide to find out.

5 minutes of reading

By GroupSumi

July 28, 2023

When it comes to sanding jobs, choosing the right tool is crucial for achieving precise and high-quality results. Orbital and eccentric sanders are two of the most popular options on the market. Both serve the purpose of removing unwanted material and smoothing surfaces, but each has distinct characteristics that make them more suitable for certain tasks.

When it comes to sanding tasks, choosing the right tool is crucial for achieving precise and high-quality results. Orbital and eccentric sanders are two of the most popular options on the market. Both serve the purpose of removing unwanted material and smoothing surfaces, but each has distinct characteristics that make them more suitable for certain jobs.

What is an orbital sander?

The orbital sander is a handheld tool that performs circular and random sanding movements. It uses sandpaper in a square or rectangular shape that adheres to a base with a vibrating mechanism. These random orbital movements prevent the formation of repetitive sanding patterns, which reduces scratch marks on the surface and provides a smoother finish.

Characteristics and operation of the orbital sander

The orbital sander is characterized by its lightweight design and easy handling. Its base usually measures around 5 inches, making it ideal for work on small to medium surfaces. Most orbital sanders come with a dust collection system, which helps keep the work area clean and protects the user's health.

The operation of the orbital sander is simple; when turned on, the base begins to vibrate and rotate in random orbits, which prevents the creation of grooves and unwanted marks on the surface.

Advantages of the orbital sander

Smooth and uniform finish on flat and curved surfaces.
Less chance of damaging the wood or the material being worked on due to its random orbital action.
Dust collection system that keeps the work area clean and improves visibility.
Suitable for sanding sensitive materials and delicate finishes.

Applications of the orbital sander

Surface preparation before applying paint, varnish, or sealants.
Sanding and smoothing wood in carpentry and cabinetry projects.
Restoration of antique furniture.
DIY projects at home.

What is an Orbital Sander?

The eccentric sander combines rotary and orbital sanding movements. Unlike the orbital sander, this tool rotates in an elliptical pattern, which provides an extremely smooth finish and minimizes circular marks on the surface.

Characteristics and functioning of the eccentric sander

The eccentric sander has a larger sanding base than the orbital, typically 6 inches, which makes it suitable for larger areas and tasks that require greater speed. It also features a dust collection system to keep the workspace clean.

When the eccentric sander is turned on, the base performs both rotational and orbital movements, ensuring a smooth and even sanding.

Advantages of the eccentric sander

Superior finish compared to the orbital sander, especially on large surfaces.
Less sanding time due to its larger size and efficiency.
Lower risk of leaving circular marks on the surface.
Ideal for removing imperfections and scratches from wood.

Applications of the eccentric sander

Sanding large wooden surfaces, such as tables and countertops.
Removal of paint or varnish from wide surfaces.
Restoration and renovation projects.

Comparison between orbital and eccentric sanders

Both sanders are excellent for different situations. The orbital sander is perfect for smaller, detailed jobs, especially on curved or irregularly shaped surfaces. On the other hand, the eccentric sander is more suitable for projects that involve large areas and require fast and even sanding.

The Orbital Sander will be useful if…

The orbital sander will be useful to us if the following tasks arise:

Surface Preparation: The orbital sander is ideal for preparing surfaces before applying paint, varnish, or sealants. It helps to eliminate irregularities and provides a smooth base for a perfect finish.
Wood Sanding: This tool is perfect for sanding wood in carpentry and cabinetry projects. Its random orbital action prevents the formation of scratch marks, achieving a uniform finish.
Furniture Restoration: If you are restoring antique furniture, the orbital sander is your ally. It helps you remove layers of old paint and smooth the wood to give it new life.
DIY Projects: At home, the orbital sander is useful for DIY projects such as polishing tables, chairs, shelves, and other wooden objects.
Working on Curved Surfaces: The circular and random sanding action makes it perfect for working on curved surfaces, such as edges and details on furniture.
Metal Sanding: In addition to wood, some orbital sanders can be used to sand soft metals, such as aluminum, preparing them for paint or special finishes.
Removal of Imperfections: If you have small imperfections on the surface, the orbital sander can help you level them and make the surface ready for the final finish.

The Orbital Sander will be useful if…

The eccentric sander, for its part, will be useful to us if the following tasks arise:

Sanding Large Surfaces: The eccentric sander is ideal for sanding large surfaces, such as tables, countertops, and wooden panels, due to its larger size and efficiency.
High-Quality Finishes: Its elliptical sanding pattern provides a superior finish, minimizing circular marks on the surface, making it perfect for projects that require flawless results.
Removal of Paint and Varnish: This tool is effective in removing layers of paint, varnish, or sealants from large surfaces, preparing them for a new finish.
Restoration and Renovation: In restoration projects, where extensive sanding is necessary, the eccentric sander offers speed and uniformity in sanding.
Work on Hardwoods: Its power and ability to sand quickly make it suitable for sanding hard woods like oak and walnut.
Removal of Deep Imperfections: If there are deep imperfections on the surface, the eccentric sander can efficiently remove them, leveling the surface.
Sanding Curved Surfaces: Although it is not as precise as the orbital sander on curved surfaces, the eccentric sander is capable of handling them effectively.

Which one to choose? Factors to consider

The choice between an orbital sander and a random orbital sander will depend on several factors:

Project size and surface to be sanded.
Type of material to be sanded and its sensitivity to sanding.
The need for an extremely smooth finish without circular marks.
Required speed and efficiency.

Our choice: Random Orbital Sander

Once both options of sanders have been known and analyzed, the time has come to give a verdict on which we believe is the best choice.

According to our tests, presented functionalities, versatility offered, price, and its characteristics, the best sander would be the Random Orbital Sander. This way we will have a tool that will assist us in any use we give it.

In our opinion, the eccentric sander stands out as the best option to choose when considering the purchase of a new sander, although we recommend that you always review the previously mentioned characteristics of each one, as it may be that in your specific case, the use of an orbital sander could be of greater value.

Tips for using orbital and eccentric sanders

Always wear protective goggles and a mask when sanding to protect your eyes and lungs from dust.
Start with a coarser sandpaper and then move to a finer grit for an optimal finish.
Keep moving while sanding to avoid material buildup in one spot.
Hold the sander firmly but without applying too much pressure on the surface.

Share it!

Returns within 30 days

Shop with peace of mind. If something goes wrong, we'll take care of it.

After-sales service

Any questions? Our support team will be happy to help you.

Pay how and when you want

Card, bank transfer, PayPal... Installment? We have them all.